Pilgrim Hat Cookies

A cute 4-ingredient no bake cookie in the shape of a Pilgrim Hat! Works perfect as a Thanksgiving classroom treat!

Pilgrim Hat Cookies with Reese’s

I don’t really put up a lot of decorations for Thanksgiving. I’m usually too worried about other things and Christmas is right around the corner so I don’t feel like decorating for both. So I make up for it by making cute Thanksgiving treats, like these Pilgrim Hat Cookies , instead!

If you like to embellish your Thanksgiving table with cute treats, then you’ll love these Reese’s Cup Turkey Treats and these Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie Turkeys , too!

• Reese’s Cup Turkey Treats
• Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie Turkeys

What You’ll Need

12 Fudge Stripe Cookies

1 tube Yellow Cookie Icing

12 Reese’s, Unwrapped

12 Orange Reese’s Pieces

How to Make Pilgrim Hat Cookies

Lay out 12 fudge stripe cookies on parchment paper with the stripe side down.

Draw circles a little larger than the widest side of the Reese’s onto the center of the cookies with the yellow icing.

Place unwrapped Reese’s into the icing.

Put a dab of icing onto the back of an orange Reese’s Pieces and ‘glue’ onto the hat to create a buckle on the hat. Repeat until all cookies are done.

Free Printables You Might Also Like

• Happy Friendsgiving Gift Tags
• Thanksgiving Blessing Mix Bag Toppers
• Thanksgiving Blessing Mix Gift Tags
• Thanksgiving Gift Tags
• Thanksgiving Coloring Book
• Thankful for Sweet Friends Like You
• Thankful for the Hands That Teach Me

More Thanksgiving Treats for Kids

• Fall Snack Mix
• Blessing Snack Mix
• Acorn Donut Holes
• Pumpkin Patch Dirt Cake Pudding Cups
• Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie Turkeys
• Reese’s Cup Turkey Treats
• Nutter Butter Pretzel Turkeys
• Pumpkin Patch Brownie Bites
• Acorn Kisses Treats
• Haystack Cookies
• 10 Cute Thanksgiving Turkey Candy Treats