Kid-Friendly

Nutter Butter Football Cookies

Nutter Butter Football Cookies, a fun, easy, and festive way to jazz up your football game day party spread!

  • Prep30 minutes
  • Total30 minutes
  • Yield15 servings

Published 6 Feb 2024

Nutter Butter Football Cookies

A fun, easy, and festive way to jazz up your football game day party spread!

Nutter Butter Footballs

Naturally football season means snacks! We love these Cheesy Ranch Crackers , Easy Taco Dip , and these Nutter Butter Football Cookies!

And for Valentine’s Day, you can give these to your child’s football loving classmates along with my Free Printable Football Valentine’s!

What You’ll Need

15 Nutter Butters

2 cups Chocolate Chips

1 packet Store-Bought White Cookie Icing

How to Make Nutter Butter Football Cookies

Line baking pan with parchment paper.

Melt 2 cups chocolate chips in the microwave in 30 second intervals, removing from the microwave and stirring before returning to the microwave each time until the chocolate is melted and smooth.

Dunk a Nutter Butter into the melted chocolate, tap access chocolate off, and place onto parchment paper lined pan. Repeat until cookies are covered in chocolate.

Chill until firm.

Follow instructions on the back of a store-bought package of white cookie icing to prepare it for use.

Then draw football laces on top of the cookies.

Chill until firm.

You Might Also Like

Pumpkin Cheesecake Snickerdoodles

Icing – Be sure not to cut the tip of the icing packet too big. A narrow line of icing is easier to control, helping to make the lines look like laces!

Practice – Practice drawing the laces on a paper plate, or something else, before ‘drawing’ the laces on to get a feel of how to best control the icing.

Flat S urface – Be sure to set the cookies down on a flat surface after ‘drawing’ the laces on so the icing doesn’t run.

More Game Day Snacks

Cheesy Ranch Crackers

Beer Dip

Easy Taco Dip

More recipes

See the category
English Muffin Cheese Pizzas
Main Dishes

English Muffin Cheese Pizzas

English Muffin Cheese Pizzas are a quick and easy meal made with toasted English muffins, pizza sauce, and melty cheese! Perfect for lunch or dinner!

20 minutes · 8 servings

Reindeer Donuts
Kid-Friendly

Reindeer Donuts

Adorable, festive holiday treats that turn simple donuts into cute, edible reindeer for Christmas morning breakfast!

30 minutes · 12 servings

Oreo dirt cake cups with chocolate pudding and cookie crumbs
Halloween

Oreo Dirt Cake Cups

Crushed Oreos, creamy pudding mixture, and gummy worms make these ‘dirt’ like treats fun for even the kids at heart!

30 minutes · 12 servings

Mini Calzones
Main Dishes

Mini Calzones

A folded pizza dough pocket stuffed with your favorite savory fillings! These are perfect for a quick meal or packed lunches!

30 minutes · 8 servings

Cake Batter Puppy Chow
Birthday

Cake Batter Puppy Chow

A fun and festive birthday treat! This puppy chow tastes just like a slice of birthday cake, but in snack form!

20 minutes