Valentine's Day

Pillsbury Heart Cookie Sandwiches

Pillsbury Heart Cookie Sandwiches, semi-homemade, cute little 2-ingredient heart shaped Valentine cookies that are super easy to make!

  • Prep30 minutes
  • Total30 minutes
  • Yield10 servings

Published 13 Feb 2025

Pillsbury Heart Cookie Sandwiches

Cute little 2-ingredient heart shaped Valentine cookies that are super easy to make!

2-Ingredient Heart Sandwich Cookies

He gave us directions to his house so we stopped by later in the day to pick them up. It was one of the nicest visits we’ve ever had! It was short but sweet, and we left with two pair of shoes instead of one!

I noticed a sign that hung in his garage about the value of making mistakes. I told him that I loved the sign and that our thinking aligned. He went on to explain the importance of trying and not to care what anyone else thinks. Then he explained that if someone wants to learn how to dance, but they are too embarrassed to try, they need to get over their embarrassment and try any way because people watch the best dancers, not the worst. I wanted to say, “You’ve never seen me dance!” HA!

In the short time I spent with him, I felt so encouraged and so terrible at the same time. I really, really misjudged him. He expects people to try their hardest, so his competitiveness isn’t what I thought it was. It’s his way of pushing people to play up to their potential. I went from cringing to applauding!

It’s the season of love! Make a batch of these 2-ingredient Pillsbury Heart Cookie Sandwiches to celebrate Valentine’s Day!

If you like cute, but easy, then I think you’ll these Rice Krispie Valentine Hearts , Valentine’s Day Cinnamon Rolls , Valentine Peanut Butter Blossoms , or Valentine Peanut Butter Cookie Cups !

What You’ll Need

1 (7.2 oz) box Pillsbury Heart Cutout Sugar Cookie Dough

1 (16 oz) Pillsbury Cream Cheese Frosting

How to Make Pillsbury Heart Cookie Sandwiches

Bake 1 (7.2 oz) box Pillsbury Heart Cutout Sugar Cookie Dough according to the directions on the box.

Let cool.

Spread frosting on the inside of half the cookies. Press the remaining cookies on top to make sandwiches.

You Might Also Like

More Valentine Treats

Love Bug Oreo Cookies

Cupid’s Crunch Chex Mix

Valentine Puppy Chow

Valentine M&M Cookie Bars

Valentine Peanut Butter Cookie Cups

Wawje!

More recipes

See the category
Raspberry brownies on a baking tray
Valentine's Day

Raspberry Brownies

Rich, fudgy Raspberry Brownies made with fresh raspberries and deep chocolate flavor! An easy dessert recipe everyone will love!

1 hour · 16 servings